By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 22, 2026

Jay Gardiner can owe his father a useful lesson without owing him forgiveness for their entire relationship. That seems fair to me, even when the lesson might help him escape the inside of a sperm whale. Surviving because you remembered someone’s advice gives you a reason to be grateful. What you do with the hurt is a separate matter.
Whalefall puts those feelings under extraordinary pressure. Jay, played by Austin Abrams, goes looking for his dead father’s remains and ends up with roughly an hour of oxygen left. His father’s knowledge becomes something he can reach for when his options have narrowed to almost nothing.
There is an obvious emotional appeal to a dead parent helping their child through remembered advice. I’m susceptible to it. A familiar instruction arriving just when someone needs it can get to me faster than a farewell speech.
But I find myself protective of Jay here. He should be allowed to remember something valuable without having to revise every difficult memory attached to the person who taught it.
Being Right About Diving Only Gets You So Far
Parents sometimes have a way of treating one correct prediction as a lifetime appointment to being right.
You forgot the coat. You got cold. This will now be mentioned at family gatherings until you are forty.
Usually it is harmless enough. In a strained relationship, though, being right can acquire a peculiar authority. Practical experience starts doing service as proof of wisdom about everything else. A father knows what to do in the water, so perhaps his son should have listened more generally.
That is a leap worth questioning.
Jay’s father, played by Josh Brolin, has knowledge his son needs. The film’s premise gives that knowledge enormous weight. We are watching a young man in danger, and anything that might help him becomes precious.
Still, expertise has limits. Knowing how to handle a dangerous situation says little about how someone handles another person’s vulnerability. A father might teach a child to stay calm while making it difficult for that child to admit fear.
For me, that is where the interesting article sits inside the survival thriller. Jay can recognise his father’s competence while retaining his own judgment about their relationship. He experienced both. He gets a say.
The Way You Learned Something Stays With You
Think about being taught to drive by someone who was already annoyed before you started the engine.
You may remember the practical advice perfectly. You may also remember the sigh when you stalled, or the particular silence that made you wish you had paid an instructor.
Years later, you can be a perfectly capable driver and still hate having that person in the passenger seat.
A lesson leaves more than information behind. There is the experience of being a beginner around someone. Whether they gave you time. Whether a question was welcome. How stupid you felt when you needed something explained again.
That distinction matters when thinking about Jay. His father’s lessons have survived in him, ready to be used. The emotional circumstances surrounding them can survive just as stubbornly.
We tend to simplify this once a parent dies. A remembered instruction becomes tender because the voice is gone. And it can be tender. There is something painfully ordinary about missing the sound of someone telling you what to do.
The tenderness may arrive alongside resentment. I trust that mixture more than a memory suddenly becoming warm all the way through.
Jay Is the One Who Has to Make It Work

The whale gives Jay an immediate problem. He needs to think while frightened, with a shrinking supply of air and almost no margin for getting things wrong.
Remembered advice can help. Applying it is his responsibility.
This gets overlooked in stories about demanding fathers. The son achieves something difficult and the achievement travels backwards, becoming evidence that the father’s methods were justified. People admire the capable adult and give surprisingly little thought to what being the child cost.
It is a convenient arrangement for the father.
Jay deserves some credit of his own. He absorbed the knowledge. He retained it. Under circumstances that would scramble almost anyone’s thoughts, he has to decide what it means for the problem directly in front of him.
There is a difference between receiving an education and using it when your life is at stake. The latter belongs to the person doing it.
I want that distinction to remain visible in Whalefall. His father can contribute to his chances without becoming the sole author of his survival. Jay brings his own judgment to the encounter, however frightened he is.
Perhaps that is part of growing away from a parent. Their instruction eventually becomes something you know. You can use it without asking them again.
Grief Puts Pressure on the Survivor to Be Generous
Jay enters the ocean looking for his father’s remains. Before the whale appears, there is already a difficult emotional task sitting inside a physical one.
A search has practical demands. You can prepare for it. You can go somewhere and look. The question of how to feel about a dead parent offers much less to work with.
There will be no further conversation. Whatever explanation or apology you once hoped for now has to remain imagined.
That can encourage a person to become generous before they are ready. You start supplying the kinder interpretation yourself. Perhaps he meant well. Perhaps you misunderstood each other. Perhaps adulthood would have made the relationship easier if there had been more time.
Some of those thoughts may be fair. Others may come from sheer exhaustion with having an argument nobody else can finish.
Jay’s need to find his father makes sense to me without requiring that search to resolve his feelings. Caring enough to go into the water already tells us something. It leaves plenty unanswered.
A person can be desperately missed and still remembered accurately. The affection deserves space. So does the memory you hesitate to mention because everyone else is being so kind.
Gratitude Can Stop at Thank You

I like a specific thank you. It feels more honest than a sweeping declaration made when emotions are running high.
That is a substantial acknowledgment on its own.
The difficulty comes when gratitude develops conditions. Once you admit that someone helped you, there can be pressure to soften everything else you have said about them. An appreciative memory gets treated as the beginning of a reconciliation you may never have offered.
Jay should have the freedom to stop at the lesson.
He might forgive his father. His understanding might change over the years. He may find himself laughing at something that used to irritate him, then discover that another memory still catches painfully.
I would rather give him those years than demand an emotional settlement while his oxygen runs out.
What moves me about the premise of Whalefall is the possibility of Jay finding something useful in a relationship he has struggled with. He gets to carry that knowledge into whatever life comes next. He can even pass it on differently, with more patience for the frightened person trying to learn.
His father taught him something worth keeping. Jay gets to decide what else comes with it.

Rachel Sikkema is a New Zealand-based writer and creative entrepreneur who explores the intersection of film, culture, and modern relationships. Through her articles, she examines how stories shape the way we connect, love and see ourselves – all for God’s glory. When she’s not writing about film and television, she’s watching Dexter and The White Lotus for the third time.