Why Watching Elizabeth Holmes for Hours Still Might Not Help You Understand Her

By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 21, 2026

Close-up of a blue eye surrounded by black-and-white halftone textures and distressed torn-paper edges.
A closer look offers few easy answers in the Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything. Image: A24. Modified by The Film Bandit.

Watching Elizabeth Holmes for hours can make you familiar with her without giving you reliable access to her motives. You learn how she speaks. You start anticipating her expressions. Eventually, recognition begins to feel like understanding. That is the uncomfortable possibility behind You Can See Everything, a documentary whose generous access leaves a stubborn question hanging over every apparent revelation. How much can another personโ€™s presence actually prove?

Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim begin with an extraordinary invitation. Thirty-four days before Holmesโ€™s incarceration, the Theranos founder and her partner Billy Evans welcome Fielder into their home to record their lives. The resulting film runs close to three hours, giving the encounter room to become something stranger than a conventional interview.

That length matters. Spend enough time watching someone and you begin to feel entitled to an answer about them. Surely all this attention should eventually pay off.

Holmes makes that bargain especially tempting. Her public image has already been examined with the intensity usually reserved for a crime scene. Another camera gets closer. We lean forward again.

Familiarity Has a Very Convincing Face

There is a small pleasure in becoming accustomed to somebody on screen. An initially peculiar mannerism becomes predictable. A voice that once demanded your attention starts to sound ordinary. You feel as though you have got past the introduction.

With Holmes, that adjustment carries a risk. Recognising how she behaves can encourage us to believe we understand why she behaves that way.

A smile offers a useful example. You might read it as reassurance or an attempt to manage the room. Someone else might see nerves. Keep watching and you may become more confident in your interpretation while the evidence remains exactly as ambiguous.

I find that more unsettling than the promise of a hidden personality waiting to emerge. The idea of a mask slipping is wonderfully convenient for an audience. It suggests that patience earns a glimpse of the truth.

People can be harder work than that. A person may be sincere about one feeling while carefully controlling the surrounding conversation. They may also believe an account of themselves that leaves enormous things unexplained.

More footage gives us more behaviour to consider. The leap from behaviour to motive still belongs to us.

A Home Gives the Story an Emotional Advantage

The domestic setting brings its own persuasive force. We are used to treating public appearances as managed occasions. A home feels closer to the place where somebody finally exhales.

See also  Why Dunkirk Feels More Like an Experience Than a Traditional Drama

That expectation gives an invitation indoors considerable power before anyone says anything.

In Holmesโ€™s case, family life also changes the emotional scale. The founder associated with a vast corporate scandal becomes a person facing separation from people she loves. Those feelings deserve to be understood on their own terms.

But affection has a limited reach as evidence. Someoneโ€™s tenderness toward their family tells us about that relationship. Questions about their professional conduct require their own answers.

Viewers can lose track of that distinction because domestic detail feels so intimate. We know how to respond to a parentโ€™s distress. The emotional response arrives quickly and has a recognisable shape.

Working through responsibility takes longer. It asks us to hold several uncomfortable facts in mind without allowing the most affecting image to settle everything.

That is where this kind of access becomes interesting to me. A camera can show a genuine feeling that an audience then gives far more explanatory weight than it can bear.

The Close-up Encourages Amateur Detective Work

A curly-haired man wearing round glasses stands in the foreground while a second man looks down behind him.
You Can See Everything explores the gap between observing someone and understanding them. Image: A24

Holmesโ€™s face invites scrutiny because viewers arrive with questions already loaded. We want a reaction that confirms something. A hesitation might do. Perhaps an answer delivered a little too smoothly.

It becomes easy to watch with the confidence of a detective and the methods of someone reading a text message three times.

There is entertainment in that. Fielderโ€™s presence makes the exercise even more appealing because awkwardness has such a strong place in his screen persona. We expect discomfort to produce a revealing moment. We wait for the conversation to catch somebody out.

Yet discomfort has many possible causes. Being filmed is one of them. Having a difficult question put to you is another. Even an apparently relaxed response gives us something to interpret rather than a clean route into another personโ€™s mind.

The camera records an expression with tremendous clarity. Our explanation for that expression can remain flimsy.

This is why I am wary of the satisfying moment when a viewer announces they can โ€œjust tellโ€ what Holmes is thinking. The certainty often arrives precisely where the explanation needs more work.

Three Hours Can Make You Overvalue Your Own Attention

A long documentary asks for an investment. By the final stretch, you have given this person a substantial part of your day. You have followed the pauses and weighed the answers.

It feels reasonable to expect some return.

That expectation can make ambiguity irritating. We may start treating every additional minute as progress toward a final verdict on somebodyโ€™s personality. We have watched so carefully. Surely we must know them better now.

See also  Smile 2 Makes the Entity Scarier Than Ever: Hereโ€™s Why

Sometimes we do. Patterns can become visible over time. Contradictions can accumulate. Sustained attention has value.

The difficulty comes when we turn that value into a guarantee. Repeated exposure can also make us more attached to our first reading. Once we decide an expression is calculating, every similar expression seems to strengthen the case.

The same thing happens with sympathy. Familiarity softens the distance. We begin supplying generous explanations because the person on screen now feels almost like someone we have met.

Either response can feel earned through careful viewing. Both deserve a little suspicion.

Mystery Should Have Limits

A blonde woman in a brown sweater looks to the left, with her hair partly pulled back beside a bright window.
Intimate access leaves difficult questions unanswered in the Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything. Image: A24

There is also a danger in making Holmesโ€™s unknowability too glamorous. An enigmatic subject is useful to a film. Every unanswered question creates another reason to keep watching.

Carry that fascination far enough and the person at the centre acquires a peculiar prestige. Their contradictions become endlessly discussable. Their capacity to hold our attention begins to look like depth.

I would rather keep the questions specific. What does an answer explain? Where does it avoid the issue? What evidence would help establish the claim being made?

Those questions are less seductive than trying to identify the โ€œrealโ€ Elizabeth Holmes. They are also more useful.

Understanding every private motive would be an impossible standard for judging anyoneโ€™s actions. We can acknowledge uncertainty about a personโ€™s inner life while remaining exacting about what they say and do.

That leaves room for empathy without asking empathy to carry the entire argument.

The most useful response to You Can See Everything may be to notice the moment you start feeling certain. What persuaded you? Was it an explanation you could examine, or simply the accumulated force of spending time in somebodyโ€™s company?

After hours with Holmes, you may recognise her mannerisms almost immediately. You may have a stronger opinion of her. The harder achievement is knowing which parts of that opinion the footage actually supports.


Discover more from The Film Bandit

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.