By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 20, 2026

We trust Nathan Fielder because he has made suspicion feel like a shared activity. His hesitant delivery and willingness to let a conversation become excruciating suggest someone who can spot the little social tricks everybody else politely accepts. In you can see everything, that familiarity gives him an enormous advantage. Elizabeth Holmes has to earn our belief. Nathan arrives with ours already waiting.
That imbalance is the most interesting way into the documentary he directed with Lance Oppenheim. We expect Holmes to manage her image. We expect Fielder to notice. Then we settle into the comfortable position of watching a potentially calculated performance alongside someone whose own performance we have learned to enjoy.
The uncomfortable possibility is that our affection for Nathan makes us less curious about Nathan.
Nathan Gets to Look Like the Person Outside the Pitch
The film begins with remarkable access. Thirty-four days before Holmes is due to enter prison, she invites a film crew into her life. A project built around that final stretch of freedom develops into a much longer undertaking. The invitation itself gives the documentary its first puzzle. What does someone hope a camera will repair?
With Holmes, viewers arrive prepared to examine every expression. Her history makes ordinary behaviour available for suspicious readings. Warmth might be persuasion. A guarded answer might look rehearsed. Even an apparently unremarkable exchange can acquire the atmosphere of a test.
Fielder benefits from a different set of expectations.
His familiar screen presence gives awkwardness a kind of credibility. He can seem uncomfortable with the very conventions that make other people persuasive. The pauses feel resistant to salesmanship. The flatness suggests a person withholding the friendly noises that usually help a conversation along.
I find that tremendously watchable. It also deserves scrutiny.
A smooth speaker can sell us confidence. Fielder can sell us the pleasure of doubting a smooth speaker. Both experiences involve a relationship with an audience. We tend to notice the transaction more quickly when we dislike the person offering it.
We Have Already Learned How to Watch Him
Anyone coming from Nathan for You or The Rehearsal brings a particular viewing habit. We look for the gap between what someone says they are doing and the stranger business unfolding around them.
Fielder has taught his audience to enjoy staying with that gap. An explanation runs too long. Somebody tries to rescue an uncomfortable exchange. The effort to make things appear normal becomes more revealing than the original problem.
That history creates a delicious expectation around Holmes. Surely Nathan will catch something. Surely the pause will get longer and the explanation will begin to buckle.
There is a little vanity in that expectation. We get to feel like the audience that understands how appearances work. Other people fall for a convincing presentation. We have watched enough Nathan Fielder to know where to look.
Well, apparently.
Recognising a filmmaker’s methods can make us unusually susceptible to them. A familiar rhythm feels like reliable company. We know when to lean forward. We recognise the sort of discomfort that usually pays off. Soon we are treating our fluency in his comedy as evidence of our judgment.
That is a very generous promotion to give ourselves.
Being Awkward Carries Its Own Authority

The crucial distinction is between observing behaviour and knowing what produced it.
A person can sound rehearsed because they are frightened. They can be charming while telling the truth. Someone who knows that every sentence may become public has ample reason to monitor themselves. The camera supplies pressure before anyone says a word.
Fielder has described feeling unsure whether Holmes was manipulating him. He has also explained that members of the crew could witness the same interaction and leave with different interpretations. That detail matters because it places uncertainty inside the filmmaking process itself.
For me, this is where the film’s central question becomes richer. How much authority do we give someone simply because their uncertainty resembles our own?
Nathan’s bafflement can feel reassuring. He seems to be working through the problem alongside us. Yet shared confusion can create loyalty as efficiently as a confident explanation. We begin trusting the companion who appears to find the same things strange.
His restraint leaves room for us to supply motives. Once we have supplied them ourselves, they can feel especially convincing. We become attached to an interpretation because we experienced the satisfaction of arriving at it.
The pleasure of figuring someone out is powerful. Sometimes it gets ahead of the evidence.
Access Still Leaves Somebody Choosing the View
The title you can see everything offers a wonderfully tempting promise. With enough access, perhaps a person will eventually become legible. Spend enough time in the room and the performance should tire itself out.
I am suspicious of that promise.
More footage gives a filmmaker more material to interpret. It gives the audience more behaviour to argue over. Neither development guarantees a final answer about what another person means.
A domestic setting can feel especially persuasive because ordinary life carries the texture of disclosure. Someone has allowed us close. We instinctively treat that closeness as progress.
But intimacy also changes the observer. Spending time with somebody can generate sympathy or irritation. Familiarity gives small gestures a history. The person holding our attention starts occupying more emotional space than the people outside the frame.
Then there is the finished film. A conversation has a beginning and an ending because somebody chooses them. A reaction becomes significant partly through its placement. Leaving an exchange unresolved is an editorial decision too.
Remembering Oppenheim’s involvement helps here. The apparent encounter between Nathan and Holmes reaches us through a collaborative work. The audience may feel alone with two difficult people while a whole filmmaking process shapes that feeling.
That craftsmanship is part of the attraction. It should remain part of the discussion.
Suspicion Can Become a Very Comfortable Seat

The weakest way to approach this film is as a contest in which our favourite perceptive man will finally identify every false note.
That expectation makes Holmes the puzzle and Fielder the answer key. It also lets the audience relax into a surprisingly passive role. We can congratulate ourselves on being sceptical while accepting somebody else’s arrangement of our scepticism.
A more demanding reading keeps our attachment to Nathan in view.
We can appreciate his patience without treating every pause as a discovery. We can find an interaction disturbing while admitting that its cause remains uncertain. Sympathy for someone facing separation from their family can coexist with a clear understanding of their responsibility for harm.
Those distinctions require more effort than deciding who won the scene. They are also where the film becomes worth arguing about.
We trust Fielder because his work has made him excellent company for uncomfortable questions. The risk comes when that company starts feeling like protection. We assume that being beside the person who notices manipulation places us safely beyond its reach.
The question I would keep returning to is simple. Why am I demanding proof of sincerity from everyone in the room except the person I was already pleased to see?

Rachel Sikkema is a New Zealand-based writer and creative entrepreneur who explores the intersection of film, culture, and modern relationships. Through her articles, she examines how stories shape the way we connect, love and see ourselves – all for God’s glory. When she’s not writing about film and television, she’s watching Dexter and The White Lotus for the third time.