When Does a Documentary Become Someone’s Second Chance at a First Impression?

By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 21, 2026

Elizabeth Holmes in a close-up portrait framed by torn paper and distressed black, cream and teal textures.
Elizabeth Holmes takes centre stage in You Can See Everything’s uneasy exploration of public image and second chances. Image: A24. Modified by The Film Bandit.

You Can See Everything becomes Elizabeth Holmes’s second chance at a first impression the moment her approaching separation from her family starts competing with what we already know about Theranos. A camera enters her home. The notorious founder becomes someone with a partner and children. Viewers receive a fresh emotional introduction to a person whose public story already carries a verdict.

That opportunity sits inside the film’s premise. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim begin documenting Holmes 34 days before she enters prison. The invitation gives them access to a life about to change, with the urgency of a countdown built into every ordinary day. The film’s official synopsis establishes that unusually charged starting point.

My answer to the title’s question is fairly simple. A documentary offers that second first impression when it makes intimacy feel like a reason to reconsider someone’s credibility. The more interesting question comes a beat later. What, exactly, has the intimacy proved?

A Home Gives a Reputation Somewhere Softer to Land

Holmes and her partner Billy Evans let the filmmakers into their San Diego beach home during the weeks before her imprisonment. That domestic setting matters. A house gives an audience different things to notice from a corporate stage or a courtroom. Someone has to move through a room. A conversation has pauses. Family life continues around the person who has become the story. Contemporary coverage describes that access.

There is real emotional force in that change of surroundings. We know how to process a disgraced executive as a public figure. Watching a parent face separation from her children asks something more personal of us.

And sympathy arrives quickly. Usually before we have decided what to do with it.

The danger comes when sympathy quietly takes on another job. Feeling someone’s distress can begin to resemble believing their account of themselves. We recognise an emotion and extend that recognition further than the evidence supports.

A person can love her family deeply while remaining responsible for serious wrongdoing. Both facts deserve their full weight. Yet a film places images in sequence, and whichever feeling arrives most vividly can start organising everything around it.

That is a substantial advantage for anyone seeking a fresh introduction. They get to meet us somewhere emotionally favourable.

Being Familiar Is a Powerful Kind of Persuasion

I find the phrase “the real person” especially slippery around documentaries like this. It suggests that enough private footage will eventually reveal a final version of someone. Keep filming and the definitive Elizabeth Holmes will emerge.

People rarely become that tidy under observation.

See also  From Dutch Angles to Lighting: Why The Substance Looks Like a Fever Dream

A private moment can be sincere and still benefit the person allowing it to be filmed. Holmes’s feelings about her family can be genuine. Those feelings also give viewers a way to imagine her beyond the identity they brought into the cinema.

The persuasive effect can happen without an explicit request for forgiveness. Familiarity does plenty of work by itself. After spending time with someone on screen, we start anticipating their reactions. Their surroundings become recognisable. We acquire the comforting sensation of knowing them.

That sensation deserves scrutiny.

Knowing how someone behaves at home gives us information about how they behave at home. It offers a limited basis for deciding whether to trust their explanations of a business scandal. The emotional leap between those two judgments is enormous. A documentary can carry us across it so smoothly that we barely feel ourselves moving.

This is where the second first impression becomes valuable. It changes the feeling attached to a name before it changes any of the facts.

Fielder Brings His Own Reputation Into the Room

Elizabeth Holmes smiles toward a child while holding a paper towel in a sunlit kitchen, with a man behind her.
A domestic moment with Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything brings the documentary’s questions about sympathy and trust into focus. Image: A24

Of course, anyone familiar with Nathan for You or The Rehearsal arrives with expectations about Fielder too. His presence encourages us to look for the awkward pause and the hidden complication. We expect a situation to become stranger the longer he stays inside it.

That expectation creates another shortcut.

Viewers may assume that a filmmaker with Fielder’s reputation has already anticipated every attempt to influence him. We can relax because someone sceptical is holding the camera. Someone will catch the trick.

I would be wary of getting too comfortable there.

A documentary’s subject has an interest in how she appears. Its filmmakers have an interest in shaping a film that holds our attention. The audience brings its own appetite for revelation. Those interests meet in the same room, and each can affect what feels significant.

Even suspicion can become a viewing pleasure. We congratulate ourselves for noticing a calculated answer. We enjoy feeling harder to fool than the people who came before us.

Holmes’s story gives that pleasure an especially uncomfortable edge. Confidence in our own judgment is exactly the sort of feeling that ought to make us pause.

Humanity Deserves Room Without Becoming a Defence

There is something ugly about requiring a disgraced person to appear monstrous in every private moment. It turns ordinary affection into a suspicious discovery. A loving gesture becomes a puzzle because we expected wrongdoing to make someone emotionally unrecognisable.

Documentaries can correct that childish expectation. They can show people living with contradictions that a headline has little room to hold.

See also  What Marty Supreme Gets Right About Power in the Internet Age

I want that complexity on screen. A film that lets us feel a family’s distress has done something worthwhile. The problem begins when the people closest to the camera acquire more moral importance simply because we can see them.

An absent person’s experience is harder to feel. Harm that happened elsewhere has to compete with the immediate presence of someone speaking in front of us. The subject has a face and time to fill. Everyone outside the frame risks becoming background information.

That imbalance demands attention from the viewer.

Compassion for Holmes’s family can exist alongside sustained attention to the conduct that brought her to this point. Keeping those thoughts together requires more effort than choosing a single emotional position. It also produces a much richer response than either easy forgiveness or the reflex to treat every tender moment as a con.

The Introduction Can Change While the History Stays

Close-up of Elizabeth Holmes smiling beside the title “You Can See Everything,” with Nathan Fielder blurred behind her.
Elizabeth Holmes fills the frame in artwork for You Can See Everything, the documentary by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. Image: A24

The question I keep returning to is what a second chance at a first impression should actually buy someone.

A fuller hearing seems fair. So does relief from the idea that one public identity explains every part of a person. A documentary can make an audience reconsider its cruelty or recognise suffering it previously found convenient to ignore.

Credibility requires something more specific.

Warmth tells us about warmth. Vulnerability tells us that a person can be hurt. Trust grows from what someone says and does when their account can be tested, particularly when accepting responsibility costs them something.

You Can See Everything gives that distinction a sharp setting. Holmes can enter the audience’s imagination again through the intimate scale of family life. We can respond to that introduction honestly. We can even feel our first impression shifting.

Then comes the harder part of watching. We have to ask which judgment has changed and why. Perhaps we understand her fear more clearly. Perhaps we feel the weight of separation. Those are meaningful responses with limits of their own.

The camera can give Elizabeth Holmes another introduction. We still decide how much credit to extend when she walks into the room.


Discover more from The Film Bandit

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.