Who Gets Forgotten When Elizabeth Holmes Becomes the Main Character Again?

By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 25, 2026

Elizabeth Holmes smiles between two figures, framed by distressed black, orange and cream torn-paper textures.
Elizabeth Holmes takes centre stage in this editorial collage for You Can See Everything. Image: A24. Modified by The Film Bandit.

The patients get forgotten first. Then the employees who questioned Theranos and had to live with the consequences of speaking up. When Elizabeth Holmes becomes the person whose face we study for clues, everyone who depended on her company risks becoming background information. Their experiences establish the stakes. Her feelings get the close-up.

That is the uncomfortable question surrounding You Can See Everything. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheimโ€™s documentary begins with extraordinary access to Holmes in the weeks before she reports to prison. The invitation is immediately absorbing. Here is someone whose public image has been examined almost to exhaustion, offering the camera a closer look at her private life. The filmโ€™s premise makes that proximity its starting point.

But proximity distributes sympathy unevenly. Spend enough time watching one person and her immediate concerns begin to organise the story. Her future becomes suspenseful. Her distress becomes recognisable. Meanwhile, the people whose lives intersected with Theranos through a blood test have to compete with the sheer pull of her presence.

Holmes gets to remain a complicated person. Everyone else can end up reduced to what happened to them.

Patients Have Lives Beyond the Evidence They Provide

A patient enters the Theranos story with a practical concern. They need information about their health. They might be waiting for reassurance or trying to understand a result that could change what happens next.

That ordinary dependence deserves more attention than it usually receives. Blood testing involves an enormous act of trust disguised as a routine appointment. You give a sample. Someone takes it away. A result comes back carrying the authority of medicine.

The person receiving it has very little opportunity to inspect the machinery behind that authority.

There is an essential legal distinction here. Holmes was convicted of investor-related fraud and conspiracy. The jury acquitted her on the patient-related counts. Any discussion of the scandal should preserve that distinction, as the trial outcome makes clear.

Patients still belong at the centre of a discussion about what Theranos promised and why reliable testing mattered. Their significance extends beyond the verdict attached to a particular defendant.

Yet patients are awkward subjects for a celebrity-driven story. Their experiences may involve appointments and uncertainty. Understanding those experiences takes patience. The camera can return to Holmesโ€™s expression and offer us something much easier to discuss.

Did she mean that? Does she believe herself? Why did she smile?

Meanwhile, someoneโ€™s relationship with their own health becomes a paragraph of context.

Speaking up Deserves More Than a Supporting Role

Elizabeth Holmes sits at a laptop in a wood-beamed room, with a filming camera filling the left foreground.
Elizabeth Holmes works at a laptop as cameras capture her daily life in You Can See Everything. Image: A24

Former Theranos employees Erika Cheung and Tyler Shultz are familiar names because they raised concerns about the company. Familiarity can create its own kind of neglect. Once someone has been assigned the role of whistleblower, we tend to treat their part in the story as settled.

See also  Whalefall and the Fear of Becoming Another Person Who Needs to Be Found

They recognised a problem. They spoke. The narrative moves on.

Cheungโ€™s testimony about her concerns over testing helps restore the practical stakes. She described discomfort with running patient samples on technology she believed was inadequate. That is a workplace decision with consequences reaching far beyond the workplace. Her testimony brings the discussion back to the people relying on those results.

There is an entire human story inside the gap between noticing something wrong and deciding to act. A junior employee has to weigh their own judgment against the confidence of people above them. They have to consider what challenging that confidence could do to their career.

A founderโ€™s certainty photographs beautifully. An employee checking whether they can trust their own conclusions takes more effort to dramatise.

I find that imbalance irritating. We remain endlessly curious about how an ambitious person justified continuing. The person who decided they could no longer continue gets a much shorter psychological examination.

Their integrity becomes a useful plot development. Holmesโ€™s contradictions become the main attraction.

Even Suspicion Keeps Her at the Centre

A documentary can approach Holmes with considerable scepticism and still make her the gravitational centre of every conversation it produces.

That is what makes this more complicated than a straightforward accusation of image rehabilitation. Viewers can distrust her completely and remain absorbed in her. Anger also holds attention. So does the pleasure of believing you have spotted a performance.

Fielderโ€™s involvement adds another personality for audiences to interpret. His familiar discomfort encourages scrutiny of the encounter itself. We start thinking about what he believes, what he is testing and how much control either person has over the exchange.

Those are worthwhile questions about filmmaking. They also give us another reason to keep looking at the people with the greatest command of the screen.

Soon the discussion becomes an elaborate contest of perception. Who understands whom? Who has anticipated the other personโ€™s response? How much have we worked out?

The patients have very little to gain from our confidence that we can read a face.

That is where an absorbing film can produce a narrowing conversation. We may leave with more sophisticated thoughts about performance while giving less thought to the ordinary people whose trust made the original promises consequential.

Sympathy Follows the Person We Spend Time With

Private access gives a subject emotional detail. A pause becomes meaningful because we have learned how the person usually speaks. A small change in expression registers. Repetition creates familiarity, even when trust remains absent.

See also  How Dunkirk Turns Time Into a Weapon

Anyone making an intimate documentary works with that effect. Anyone watching one is susceptible to it.

Holmesโ€™s family life introduces real emotional stakes. Her children deserve privacy and care. The prospect of separation can be painful to contemplate. A viewer can respond to that pain honestly.

The harder task is keeping other people emotionally present while the camera offers so much access to one household.

People affected by Theranos had households too. Their worries arrived in kitchens and bedrooms. They had someone to call after an unsettling appointment or a difficult day at work. Those lives continue beyond the moments that make them relevant to Holmesโ€™s biography.

A film gives us access to particular people. We have to resist treating that access as a measure of whose experience matters most.

Let Someone Else Have the Unfinished Story

Elizabeth Holmes wears round glasses and a brown sweater, looking to the side while seated in a car with her seatbelt on.
Elizabeth Holmes sits in a car in You Can See Everything, which brings her private life into focus. Image: A24

Holmes is granted an apparently inexhaustible future as a subject. There is always another question about who she has become. Another opportunity to reconsider her voice or examine her account of herself.

The people around the scandal are more often held in place. The patient remains a patient. The employee remains a witness. Their narrative usefulness can end once they have explained the damage or helped us understand the company.

I would like more curiosity about what followed for them. What happened to their confidence? How did they approach the next workplace or the next medical appointment? Which parts of their lives moved on easily, and which required work?

Those questions deserve room without requiring anyone to return to public view or perform their distress for a camera.

The strongest response to another Holmes-centred story is to notice where our own curiosity goes. If we can spend hours wondering whether she understands herself, we can spend longer considering the people who had to make decisions under the conditions Theranos created.

Elizabeth Holmes already has our attention. The people at the edges of her story deserve the chance to occupy the centre of their own.


Discover more from The Film Bandit

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.