By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 23, 2026

Yes. You can feel sorry for Elizabeth Holmes and still hold her responsible for Theranos. You can find something sad about her life without deciding that the people who trusted her should put everything behind them. Sympathy becomes a problem when it starts doing the work of an excuse.
I think most of us understand this in our own lives. We have felt sorry for someone who treated us badly. We have understood why a person was frightened or desperate and still wished they had made a different choice.
Put a camera in front of that person, though, and the feelings become strangely difficult to sort out. A close-up makes their distress immediate. The consequences of their actions may be somewhere else, represented by a few sentences of background.
Holmes gets a face. Everyone else risks becoming part of the explanation.
You Can Believe That Someone Is Hurting
There is a temptation with Holmes to inspect every expression for evidence of calculation. A pause becomes suspicious. A vulnerable moment gets examined as though sincerity could be established by watching it again at half speed.
I understand the impulse. Her story gives viewers reason to be careful about persuasion.
Still, assuming that every feeling must be manufactured makes the whole exercise rather easy. You can dismiss the person before they have finished speaking. Nothing they say can reach you because you have already decided what every word means.
I would rather allow for the possibility that the distress is real.
A person can be upset about the damage to their life while remaining evasive about how it happened. They can speak honestly about loneliness and offer a much less satisfactory account of their decisions. Feelings have their own truth. They tell us only so much about the surrounding events.
That is where I want an interviewer to stay alert. Give someone time to compose themselves, certainly. Then return to the question.
The Person on Screen Gets a Head Start
Spend enough time with somebody in a film and small details begin to matter.
You notice when they seem tired. You recognise the expression that comes before an uncomfortable answer. An ordinary laugh can make them suddenly familiar. You start feeling that you know a little about how they move through the world.
Other people in the story often receive a fraction of that attention.
They might appear to describe a consequence, establish a fact or challenge something the central figure has said. Their lives before and after that moment remain largely outside the film. We know what happened to them. We have had less opportunity to know them.
This matters enormously in a portrait of Holmes.
She already has the advantage of recognition. An audience arrives knowing her name and wanting to understand her. People affected by Theranos have to earn attention within a story that has been organised around somebody else.
A film can give their experiences proper weight. It can also hurry through them because Holmes is available for another revealing conversation.
I tend to notice the imbalance afterwards. The scenes with the central figure remain vivid, while everyone else has blurred into the background. That can happen even when a film has included the necessary facts. Emotional attention follows its own timetable.
Feeling Familiar Can Make Someone Seem Reasonable

The most persuasive explanation is sometimes the one that reminds you of yourself.
Fear of failure is familiar. So is wanting to impress people who believe in you. Most of us have postponed an uncomfortable admission because we hoped we could fix the problem first.
Recognising that feeling in a powerful person can be useful. It helps explain how ordinary weaknesses might survive inside an extraordinary situation.
But I get uneasy when recognition starts closing down the discussion.
โI understand how that could happenโ can become a comfortable place to stop. We supply the rest of the explanation ourselves. Pressure builds. Things get out of hand. The person keeps going because stopping would be awful.
All of which leaves the actual choices waiting to be examined.
Who needed accurate information? What was said to them? When did protecting the person making the promise become more important than protecting the person relying on it?
Those questions may feel harsh during a sympathetic moment. They are also the questions that give the sympathy some perspective.
Holmes can be understandable without every decision becoming understandable in the same way. Some parts of a personโs experience will feel close to our own. Others deserve a much harder look.
Sadness About Losing Your Lifeโs Work Can Fill a Film
There is an obvious drama in watching someone lose the future they imagined.
A person once associated with success has to explain what remains. The audience can follow that reversal easily. It has a shape we recognise, and the subjectโs grief supplies plenty of emotion.
The trouble is how much room that story can take up.
A portrait of Holmes could spend a long time on her disappointment and still leave us with little understanding of what she believes she owes other people. Being devastated by an outcome tells us that the outcome hurt. Responsibility requires more detail.
I find myself listening for plain sentences.
Does she describe a decision clearly? Does she acknowledge what another person reasonably expected from her? Can she stay with their experience for a moment without bringing the conversation back to what she intended?
Those answers would matter more to me than how moved I felt watching her speak.
Someone can deliver a very sad account of their own losses. The missing piece may still be an adequate account of anyone elseโs.
We Are Generous With Forgiveness That Belongs to Others
I have always found it odd how quickly an audience can decide that somebody deserves to be forgiven.
We have spent an evening with them. We have seen a softer side. It feels ungenerous to remain where we started, so we begin talking about second chances.
People directly affected may have spent years with the consequences. Their response could be much less tidy.
They might want an apology that addresses something specific. They might want distance and might have stopped following Holmesโs life altogether and resent being asked to provide an emotional response to the latest portrait.
I think they are entitled to that.
Compassion for Holmes should leave room for people who remain angry. Otherwise, the sympathetic account starts making demands of the very people whose experience it ought to consider. They become responsible for demonstrating generosity so the rest of us can enjoy a sense of closure.
That is a lot to ask.
An audience can hope that someone changes. It can support humane treatment. It can even be moved by evidence of remorse. The people involved still get to decide whether trust is possible again.
I Would Rather Keep the Uncomfortable Feeling

A portrait of Holmes might make me feel sorry for her. I can imagine leaving it sadder than I expected, with less appetite for the jokes and caricatures that gather around a public downfall.
That would be a worthwhile response.
I would also want to remember which questions the film answered and which it softened. Sometimes the most affecting scene is precisely the one that makes a follow-up feel rude. You have seen someone struggle. Asking for more starts to seem cruel.
Yet a difficult question can be asked with care. Someoneโs humanity survives being expected to answer it.
You can wish Holmes less suffering without wishing away responsibility. You can acknowledge her distress while noticing how little time another person received to describe theirs. Those responses may remain awkwardly together. There is no need to force them into a single feeling before the credits finish.
Feel sorry for her if you do. Then listen just as carefully when somebody else explains why they are still angry.

Rachel Sikkema is a New Zealand-based writer and creative entrepreneur who explores the intersection of film, culture, and modern relationships. Through her articles, she examines how stories shape the way we connect, love and see ourselves – all for God’s glory. When she’s not writing about film and television, she’s watching Dexter and The White Lotus for the third time.