By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 25, 2026

Jay Gardiner’s search for his father’s remains turns grief into a job he can finish. That is the painful idea driving Whalefall. A damaged relationship has survived the man himself, and Jay enters the ocean carrying the hope that retrieving a body might finally settle what happened between them. My reading is that his deepest struggle concerns the permission to keep living while some of those feelings remain unresolved.
There is something horribly persuasive about that bargain. Find your father. Bring him home. Perhaps then you can stop wondering whether you failed him.
Brian Duffield’s adaptation of Daniel Kraus’s novel gives that emotional burden a brutally physical shape. Austin Abrams plays Jay opposite Josh Brolin as his father, Mitt. Jay’s recovery dive leaves him swallowed by a sperm whale with an hour of air, dependent on lessons Mitt taught him. Even inside another creature’s body, his father occupies an enormous amount of space.
Giving Grief Something to Do
The search for remains has an obvious practical purpose. It also offers Jay a seductive kind of order. Underwater, there is somewhere to look and equipment to operate. He can commit himself to an action with a visible result.
Try doing that with a relationship.
What would count as completing the work of being Mitt’s son? One more conversation? An apology with the right words? A memory strong enough to make the painful ones easier to carry? Death removes the possibility of asking while leaving the questions perfectly intact.
I find that aspect of Whalefall more troubling than the premise’s sheer grotesqueness. Jay gives himself a task that seems capable of answering an emotional question. The ocean might contain his father’s remains. Whether finding them would make him feel like a better son is another matter entirely.
That distinction matters because effort can become its own trap. Once grief has a mission attached to it, stopping can feel like abandonment. Turning back becomes another decision you might spend years defending to yourself.
A diving tank is a particularly cruel object to bring into that arrangement. It puts a limit on how much of yourself you can spend.
A Dead Father Can Still Set the Terms

Mitt’s presence in the story continues through Jay’s memories and the knowledge he carries into the water. The father remains involved in his son’s decisions after his death. The flashback structure gives that ongoing influence a literal place alongside Jay’s immediate struggle.
There is a familiar pressure surrounding difficult parents once they die. Their lives become easier to summarize. People reach for the generous explanation. A harsh demand becomes an expression of concern. An old injury starts attracting suggestions that you should understand it differently now.
Some of those explanations may contain truth. The pressure comes from having to accept them as the final version.
For a son in Jay’s position, mourning can begin to resemble another performance with standards to meet. You should remember enough good. You should arrive at forgiveness. Eventually, you should be able to tell the story without making everyone uncomfortable.
The word “closure” makes this sound soothing. It can also sound like a deadline.
What interests me about Jay’s predicament is how thoroughly it denies him the room to produce a polished account of his father. He has a body to keep alive. His memories arrive inside an emergency. Whatever understanding he reaches has to coexist with fear and the practical business of getting another breath.
There is something honest in that disorder. Feelings rarely wait until we have the time to express them properly.
Useful Lessons Carry Complicated Debts
The cruelest part of the setup is Jay’s dependence on what Mitt taught him. His father’s knowledge has practical value in the very situation that threatens to kill him.
That creates an uncomfortable question. If a parent gave you something that helps you survive, how much gratitude do you owe them?
I think the answer has to leave room for the circumstances in which that knowledge was passed down. A useful lesson remains useful. The experience of learning it remains part of the relationship too. Jay can carry his father’s expertise into the future along with a clear memory of what being his son cost him.
Films about difficult fathers sometimes lean heavily on the revelation that Dad was preparing his child for a harsh world. A later crisis arrives and suddenly the childhood training pays off. The usefulness of the lesson starts doing suspicious amounts of moral work.
Whalefall puts enormous pressure on that possibility. Jay needs the knowledge now. There is barely room to question where it came from.
As a viewer, I want to keep that question open for him.
His ability to use what he learned also belongs to Jay. He has to remember it under pressure and decide how it applies. Giving Mitt credit for teaching him leaves plenty of credit for the young man doing the surviving. Parents provide parts of our equipment. We are the ones who eventually have to carry it.
The Whale Makes Closure Feel Urgent
The premise almost dares us to demand a breakthrough. Put a grieving son inside a whale and we start waiting for the emotional revelation that will accompany his escape. A situation this extreme seems to promise an equally dramatic piece of understanding.
That expectation is worth being suspicious of.
It places a second demand on Jay while he is already fighting for his life. Somehow he must also arrive at the correct interpretation of his father. The ordeal begins to look like an expensive route to a lesson he was supposed to learn.
I prefer the messier possibility contained in the story. Remembering Mitt may help Jay survive while leaving parts of their relationship painful. A moment of tenderness can matter enormously without becoming the authorized explanation for every year that came before it.
The whale’s body gives this argument an ugly physical force. Jay’s remaining air keeps being spent regardless of how far he has progressed toward understanding. His body has an urgent claim on him.
He deserves the next breath while he is still confused.
Let the Son Have a Future

The closure promised by recovering a body is appealing because it gives grief an endpoint we can picture. There would be something to bring back. There would be a task completed.
A relationship asks more awkward things of the person left behind. Jay has to decide what to carry forward from Mitt and how much authority those memories will have. That work can continue long after any single act of recovery.
For me, the strongest way to read Whalefall is to keep Jay’s right to a future at the center. Understanding his father can be part of that future. So can anger. So can an ordinary afternoon when his attention belongs to something else.
There is a quiet cruelty in expecting a grieving child to make a parent’s death meaningful. It hands them responsibility for the ending of someone else’s story while their own life is still taking shape.
Jay goes into the ocean looking for his father. The most urgent thing he has to bring back is himself.

Rachel Sikkema is a New Zealand-based writer and creative entrepreneur who explores the intersection of film, culture, and modern relationships. Through her articles, she examines how stories shape the way we connect, love and see ourselves – all for God’s glory. When she’s not writing about film and television, she’s watching Dexter and The White Lotus for the third time.