You Can See Everything and Our Obsession With the Perfect Confession

By Rachel Sikkema
Published October 26, 2026

Elizabeth Holmes wearing glasses and a seatbelt, framed by distressed black, cream and red torn-paper textures.
Elizabeth Holmes and the search for the perfect confession in You Can See Everything. Image: A24. Modified by The Film Bandit.

The confession we want from Elizabeth Holmes would probably disappoint us. She could acknowledge the lies, explain her decisions and express remorse in plain language. Plenty of us would still watch her face and wonder whether she had rehearsed it. You Can See Everything gets at that uncomfortable problem. Once someone has sold the world a story, even their attempt to come clean can sound like another pitch.

That is what makes the film’s encounter with Holmes so absorbing. There are reasonable questions to ask about what she knew and how she justified carrying on. But underneath those questions sits a more personal demand. We want her to understand herself the way we understand her. We want to hear the words that tell us she finally gets it.

And, preferably, we would like Nathan Fielder to be there when it happens.

We Have Already Written Her Big Scene

You can picture the confession people are waiting for. Holmes stops explaining herself quite so carefully. Something gives. She acknowledges a decision in language that leaves her very little room to manoeuvre.

The appeal is obvious. After so much attention paid to her public image, a plain admission would feel like solid ground.

But we also have expectations about the delivery. She should seem upset, though too much distress might look like a request for sympathy. She should answer clearly, though a fluent answer might sound prepared. A pause could suggest that she is choosing her words honestly. It could also look like she is working out what she can get away with.

Good luck getting that performance right.

I think this is where our perfectly reasonable desire for accountability becomes tangled up with something else. We want the emotional satisfaction of catching a person at the exact moment they surrender their preferred version of events. We want to see it happen to them.

An admission offered calmly over a table might tell us more. The messy breakdown would probably get replayed more often.

Holmes Keeps Being a Person

One of the awkward things about giving a camera access to someone’s daily life is that daily life carries on. A person with an appalling public reputation still has ordinary exchanges. They can be affectionate. They can worry about what happens next. People who love them may continue loving them.

That can be surprisingly irritating to watch.

There is a punitive little voice that wants every moment to reflect the seriousness of the history involved. Should she be smiling? Why does she seem comfortable? How can this conversation be so ordinary?

Of course a person cannot spend every waking minute visibly contemplating their wrongdoing. We know that. Put a camera in front of Elizabeth Holmes and the expectation creeps back anyway.

See also  Who Gets Forgotten When Elizabeth Holmes Becomes the Main Character Again?

Her approaching imprisonment gives the film an immediate source of emotion. Fear about losing your freedom is easy to understand. So is the distress of being separated from your family. Viewers can recognise those feelings without having resolved anything about her account of Theranos.

The difficulty comes when we start treating sympathy as a decision we must either approve or reject. You can feel awful watching someone face a consequence they brought upon themselves. That response leaves you free to keep asking difficult questions.

Holmes does not have to become less human for those questions to matter.

We Become Experts in What Her Eyes Are Doing

Close-up of Elizabeth Holmes looking upward with a slight smile, her face illuminated by dim blue light.
Elizabeth Holmes in close-up in You Can See Everything, a documentary that puts sincerity under scrutiny. Image: A24

The eye contact between Holmes and Fielder is almost absurdly watchable. She insists on her sincerity. He looks at her. We look at both of them.

Before long, it is tempting to believe that the answer must be somewhere in her expression.

I know the impulse. Watch a public apology online and you can spend an embarrassing amount of time studying one tiny pause. Why did they smile there? Why did they look down before answering? You replay it and feel as though you are getting somewhere.

Sometimes you are simply watching a person look down twice.

With Holmes, suspicion arrives before the footage does. Her history gives us reason to question what she says. It also makes us liable to read every movement as confirmation of a conclusion we already hold.

A steady gaze becomes calculated. Nervousness becomes guilt. Warmth becomes an attempt to win us over. Once every possible response fits the theory, the exercise starts losing its value.

That hardly means we should take her at her word. It means her words deserve closer examination than our confidence in reading her face.

What did she actually acknowledge? What did the answer leave out? Those are less exciting questions than wondering whether you have just seen the mask slip. They are also questions you can do something with.

Fielder Makes the Wait Feel Worthwhile

Fielder’s presence adds a particular pleasure to all this. He is very good at making you believe an uncomfortable conversation still has somewhere to go.

Most people would rescue a stalled exchange. Ask an easier question. Laugh a little. Give everyone an exit. His familiar screen manner makes staying put seem like a reasonable option.

So we stay with him.

There is an expectation built into that relationship with the audience. If the silence lasts long enough, perhaps Holmes will say something she would otherwise have kept to herself. We are waiting for his patience to produce the breakthrough.

It is a satisfying setup for anyone who has wanted a powerful person to face a follow-up question instead of being allowed to move on.

See also  How Casino Royale Rebuilt 007’s Soul From Scratch

Still, our affection for Fielder can make us generous towards his side of the encounter. We recognise his awkwardness and know how to enjoy it. Hers arrives under suspicion. We may scrutinise her performance while accepting his as the familiar thing that helps us watch.

That imbalance is worth sitting with. He can ask a revealing question. The answer still needs judging on what it contains, however much we enjoy the person asking it.

An Apology Has Work to Do Afterwards

The confession fantasy also has a practical weakness. It tends to end when the speaker finishes talking.

The person admits what they did. Someone across the table absorbs it. We feel that a corner has been turned. Then the scene ends at exactly the point where responsibility becomes less cinematic.

What happens with the admission? Does it correct an account that was false? Does it acknowledge someone whose warnings were dismissed? Will the speaker stand by it when doing so becomes inconvenient?

Specific answers matter here. Regret can spread itself very comfortably across a conversation without attaching to any particular choice.

A person can feel terrible about how their life turned out. They can be sincere about that feeling. They may still owe a much more direct account of how other people got hurt.

This is why I am wary of treating visible emotion as the prize in an interview with Holmes. Tears would give us something to react to. A precise answer could give us something to examine tomorrow.

We Want Permission to Stop Watching

Extreme close-up of a blue eye with a man’s face reflected in it and rainbow fringes around the eyelids.
A face reflected in a blue eye evokes You Can See Everything’s questions about observation and trust. Image: A24

There is a slightly selfish wish underneath the search for the perfect confession. We want to be finished with her.

You Can See Everything keeps that desire uncomfortably close to the surface. The access encourages us to keep looking. Our suspicion supplies an endless reason to look again.

Perhaps the useful response is to become more modest about what we need from a confession. An accurate admission matters even if the speaker remains difficult to read. Accountability can proceed while our curiosity goes hungry.

Holmes could say exactly what a viewer has waited years to hear. I suspect a lot of us would reach for the replay button anyway.

Just to check that pause before she said it.


Discover more from The Film Bandit

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.